TRUNITY
  • Home
  • Why Trunity
  • Catalog
  • HMH
  • Log In

 

The Environmental Citizen

 

Losing the Forest for the Trees

7/16/2018

1 Comment

 
Sustainability Policy and Events, Activity
Picture
Dogwood Alliance. "Stop Thinking of Europe as Climate Leaders", Rita Frost, June 28th, 2018
According to a 2015 report featured by the Ecological Society of America, old growth forests store 30% more carbon than younger forests (“Carbon storage in old‐growth forests of the Mid‐Atlantic: toward better understanding the eastern forest carbon sink”, McGarvey, Thompson, Epstein, Shugart).  It certainly makes sense that the older and bigger the tree, the more carbon it is storing in the form of wood.  Common sense tells you this.  And the older the forest, the better it works at this critical job.  Now imagine those forests cut down and replaced with a plantation of saplings, each storing orders of magnitude less carbon, while the world desperately needs carbon pulled out of the atmosphere.
​
The various strategies we usually hear about for addressing our warming globe involve switching from fossil fuels to solar and wind.  But the carbon already present will stay for hundreds of years.  We need to remove it as well.  Fossil fuel supporters have long promoted carbon capture and storage, but it has remained prohibitively unprofitable.  Carbon utilization technologies, such as fixation by algae or conversion to industrial chemicals, are a new focus, exemplified by the FUEL Act now before Congress, supported by the Carbon Utilization Research Council, which is made up primarily of coal interests.  A March, 2015 review in the Journal of CO2 Utilization concluded that global warming can be reduced by these technologies but substantial problems of cost-effectiveness and the fact that many cause other environmental impacts must be overcome. (“Carbon capture, storage and utilisation technologies: A critical analysis and comparison of their life cycle environmental impacts”, Cuéllar-Franca, Azapagicas).  However, as Dr. William Moomaw of Tufts’ Fletcher School points out, we already have an extremely effective device for carbon sequestration: the tree.  
In fact, Moomaw and Danna Smith of the Dogwood Alliance wrote in the recent report The Great American Stand that “if we halted deforestation, protected existing forests, and expanded and restored degraded forests, we could reduce annual emissions by 75 percent in the next half a century.”

When someone is accused of not seeing the forest for the trees, it is meant as a metaphor for not seeing the big picture, and risking losing everything through a narrow focus.  Now the metaphor is horribly real.  If we believe that biomass fuels such as wood pellet furnaces are carbon neutral, because a new tree can be planted to replace the one taken for burning, we will actually lose real forests, as companies see only the trees they can harvest for sale to power plants.  Although burning wood seems cleaner than burning coal, you have to burn more to get the same amount of energy, and there’s no real benefit.  Meanwhile you have replaced a rich ecosystem already storing carbon effectively with a sterile one that has vastly less carbon storage capacity and will not do anything comparable for a long time.
​
According to the US Department of Commerce (the International Trade Administration’s 2016 Top Markets Report) demand from the EU, South Korea and Japan to meet carbon emission targets is already spurring investment in pellet mills, which often use forest products.  The UK’s largest coal plant, Drax, has been converted to burning wood pellets.  The Great American Stand notes that the U.S. is now “the world’s largest manufacturer and exporter of wood pellets as an alternative to coal for generating electricity in Europe”.  Climate Home News reported (February 21, 2018) that the UK, in alliance with Poland and Spain, succeeded in “watering down” EU’s renewable directive, protecting the policy that now considers wood fuel on a par with solar and wind.  (The directive has not yet been approved by the European Parliament).    

There are many ways to appreciate the value of trees.  In 1837 George Pope Morris’ poem, Woodman, Spare that Tree, was made by Henry Russell into a popular song:

Woodman spare that tree!
Touch not a single bough;
In youth it sheltered me,
And I'll protect it now.


We have in myth, however, also celebrated Paul Bunyan’s wholesale slaughter of forests in a heroic fashion.  Which sentiment will prevail today?  When I offered the services of students in my class, “Research for Environmental Agencies and Organizations” to the Executive Office of Environmental Affairs of Massachusetts, conservation officials asked students to assist with two relevant tasks: reviewing and recommending “tree retention” policies, and assistance in developing guidance on obtaining carbon credits for forest conservation.  Students found that preserving trees has an extraordinary range of benefits, from habitat protection to reducing stormwater management costs and heat island effects, not to mention enhanced property values – homes near trees are valued more highly and are more energy efficient because of shading and cooling.  In producing a draft guidebook on how to sell carbon credits for forest conservation, students recommended the approach of “Community Credits”, where carbon credits are not sold to utilities to allow them to offset fossil fuel emissions, but instead are purchased by residents interested in using them to preserve local forests.  Community Credits “can be thought of almost as similar to a virtual farmers market that can provide new revenue to reward sustainable business practices while also reducing carbon emissions.” (See www.bu.edu/rccp, Spring 2018 Guidebook and Fall 2017 Tree Retention projects).  When you look at a tree, do you see a way to make a buck?  Or do you see a part of a forest, and sing as Americans once sang:

Here shall the wild-bird sing,
And still thy branches bend.
Old tree! the storm still brave!
And, woodman, leave the spot;
While I've a hand to save,
Thy axe shall harm it not.

​
Activity: select a geographic location. Identify forest resources and whether they are managed for conservation or are open to commercial exploitation.  Assess whether state, regional or local government has developed relevant restrictions, incentives or conservation planning.  Identify available resources for forest conservation and attempt to assess whether forests and urban trees in the location will be subject to pressure for harvesting or removal and what anticipatory policies may be developed to preserve them.
1 Comment
Allan Siegel
8/17/2018 03:07:27 pm

Rick, I finally read this. During the past month so much the West's old growth forests have gone up in flames - with more, no doubt, still to burn as summer and drought deepens. Curious about your thoughts on this in context of your article.

Thanks for this piece.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    The Environmental Citizen​ is for people who want to help meet the challenge of how to live within the biosphere without harming it, and thus protect ourselves, other living things, future generations, and the source of all wealth and value that we hold dear.  It builds on topics in the text Developing Sustainable Environmental Responsibility but is addressed to anyone interested in what each individual can do on their own, as members of the societies in which they live, and as members of the universal group - the human race.

    Designed to easily be used as classroom resources or to offer people direction, many of the articles within The Environmental Citizen include activities, questions, and recommended readings.

    I welcome your input and ideas.

    Kindly,
    Rick Reibstein

    Resources by Category

    All
    Activities
    Law For Sustainability
    Purpose And Context
    Recommended Reading
    Sustainability Policy & Events


    RSS Feed


    Picture
    Richard Reibstein
    Rick Reibstein teaches environmental law at Boston University and Harvard’s Summer School. He has helped develop toxics use reduction policy and assistance practices for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and has served as an attorney for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).  He has trained businesses and governments in developing programs for pollution prevention, compliance assistance and environmental performance improvement.  He initiated the Massachusetts Environmentally Preferable Purchasing program, founded two Business Environmental Networks and is an individual winner of the EPA’s Environmental Merit Award (2000). Reibstein has published in Pollution Prevention Review, the Environmental Law Reporter, the International Journal of Cleaner Production, the Journal of Industrial Ecology, and the Journal of Ecological Economics, as well as producing many reports, guidance and proposals as a state official.

    Sign up to receive
    ​blog posts from
    The Environmental Citizen
    Subscribe
Categories
Activities
For classes, groups, or individuals seeking to manifest more responsibility for all
  1. Activities for the Environmental Citizen
Sustainability Policy & Events
Events relative to hopes for evolving more world-responsible societies.
  1. Losing the Forest for the Trees
  2. The Great Undoing​
  3. Request for Comment: Overwhelmingly Negative Response to Administration's Environmental Plans
  4. Connecting Distributed Leadership
  5. Reasonable Expectations of Government
Recommended Reading
Opening and Grounding Perspective  
  1. Jennet Conant's Man of the Hour
  2. Louis S. Warren's God's Red Son
Purpose and Contextual Management
What are the Transformations We Should Work to Achieve?  How do we transcend our differences to effect commonality?
  1. Where Loyalty Belongs
  2. The Best Bet
  3. Connecting Distributed Leadership
Picture
Developing Sustainable Environmental Responsibility is an active learning, inquiry-based approach to teaching undergraduate and graduate level students the principles and practice of applying sustainable environmental responsibility in their discipline.
Learn more >>
Free evaluation copy for faculty

PRODUCTS

Why Trubooks
Trubook Catalog

Support

Contact
Email Support
© COPYRIGHT 2021. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • Home
  • Why Trunity
  • Catalog
  • HMH
  • Log In